Startmate CEO Michael Batko discusses community-building and portfolio construction in early-stage investing.

Startmate CEO Michael Batko discusses community-building and portfolio construction in early-stage investing.

Startmate CEO Michael Batko discusses community-building and portfolio construction in early-stage investing.

0:00/1:34

Also on

Also on

In this episode, Cheryl Mack and Maxine Minter sit down with Michael Batko, the driving force behind Startmate, to explore the intricacies of early stage investing and the power of community in the startup realm. Batko shares his journey, starting from his first investment to steering one of the most active seed stage investors in the industry. This episode offers a behind-the-scenes look at how Batko and his team utilize a community-driven approach to identify, select, and uplift transformative business ideas.

Diving into the Startmate selection process, Batko reveals the operational complexities of coordinating a vast network of mentors and how their personal investment in the fund aligns interests and boosts engagement. The conversation also uncovers the evolution of Startmate's investment thesis, its expansion into diverse industries, and Batko's approach to encouraging non-consensus thinking to unlock extraordinary potential. The episode delves into the significance of carry in VC funds, the strategic role of a continuity fund, and the decision-making framework for follow-on investments, all while reflecting on Batko's philosophy of betting on the hungry rather than the proven.

Resources

- Startmate’s success is rooted in a mentor-driven model, where community engagement and personal investment are key to its decision-making process.

- Batko emphasizes the importance of looking beyond what’s probable and considering what’s possible when evaluating investment opportunities.

- The alignment of mentor incentives with fund performance, through carry, is highlighted as a significant motivational factor.

- A robust debate around investment thesis expansion led to backing diverse ventures, including non-software startups like non-alcoholic beer brand Heaps Normal.

- The establishment of a continuity fund at Startmate allows for continuous support of alumni companies, signaling strong belief in their ongoing success.

Resources:

Startmate website for more insights into their accelerator programs. Startmate

Michael Batko’s professional background and contributions, visit LinkedIn

Discussion of eucalyptus’s ESOP primer and equity importance. Eucalyptus

This Episode Is Brought To You By Our Partners

Click our partners below to see their unique offers

More Episodes You Might Like

Let's talk

Turn podcasting into pipeline

We help founders, funds and operators build trust, authority and deal flow with a show tailored to their market.

Win better deals and stay top‑of‑mind with founders.

Close more deals and build a category you own.

Reach founders and operators with a show they trust.

Day One® exists to help founders and startup operators make better business decisions more often

Subscribe for helpful content from other successful founders, operators and investors

Join 755 other founders & investors receiving our emails. They're cool, are you? :)

* Regrettably, mel@canva.com is not on our list… yet.

Day One® is a registered trademark of W2D1 Media Pty Ltd. All rights reserved. © 2026 W2D1 Media Pty Ltd.

Day One® exists to help founders and startup operators make better business decisions more often

Subscribe for helpful content from other successful founders, operators and investors

Join 755 other founders & investors receiving our emails. They're cool, are you? :)

* Regrettably, mel@canva.com is not on our list… yet.

Day One® is a registered trademark of W2D1 Media Pty Ltd. All rights reserved. © 2026 W2D1 Media Pty Ltd.