Crafting Your Investment Thesis: How to Decide What to Invest In

Crafting Your Investment Thesis: How to Decide What to Invest In

Crafting Your Investment Thesis: How to Decide What to Invest In

0:00/1:34

Also on

Also on

Deciding what startups to invest in can feel overwhelming, but it doesn't have to be. Cheryl and Maxine unpack one of the most critical (and enjoyable!) parts of angel investing: crafting your investment thesis. Whether you're brand new to investing or an experienced angel refining your approach, this episode helps you structure your thinking and clarify exactly what to look for in potential investments.

They define exactly what an investment thesis is, why it's essential, and how it shapes your returns, risk tolerance, and overall investor experience. Cheryl and Maxine break down core elements of an investment thesis, including industry focus, stage, business model, geography, and specific company criteria such as founding teams, market size, and traction.

The hosts also discuss practical strategies for determining your unique value as an investor, improving your deal flow, and aligning your investments with your personal values and desired impact. Plus, they emphasise how thoughtful portfolio construction and clear expectations around timelines and risk tolerance can prevent common investor pitfalls, like running out of money!

If you're ready to level up your investing strategy, gain clarity in your decision-making, and build confidence in your portfolio choices, this episode provides the frameworks and insights you need.

Chapters

00:00 – Introduction: Why your investment thesis matters
01:49 – Defining an investment thesis: What it is & why it's essential
04:49 – How to break down your thesis into clear categories
05:16 – Industry focus: Verticals, horizontals, and emerging trends
07:05 – Stage focus: Pre-seed, seed, growth—how to pick your sweet spot
08:24 – Business model focus: B2B SaaS, marketplaces, and beyond
10:01 – Geography: The pros and cons of investing locally vs globally
14:29 – Key questions every investor should ask themselves
17:24 – Company-specific criteria: How to create your investment checklist
22:33 – Evaluating market size and growth potential
25:39 – Pain vs pleasure: Investing in painful problems vs unmet desires
29:54 – Unique or niche theses: Second-time founders, alumni networks, and more
33:46 – Access and deal flow: How to attract great opportunities
38:35 – Understanding your personal risk profile & timeline expectations

Resources

Angel Academy – Comprehensive angel investing course for Australia & NZ: www.venture.academy
Aussie Angels – Cheryl’s platform for angel investing https://www.aussieangels.com/
Co-Ventures – Maxine’s venture capital firm https://www.coventures.vc/

This Episode Is Brought To You By Our Partners

Click our partners below to see their unique offers

More Episodes You Might Like

Let's talk

Turn podcasting into pipeline

We help founders, funds and operators build trust, authority and deal flow with a show tailored to their market.

Win better deals and stay top‑of‑mind with founders.

Close more deals and build a category you own.

Reach founders and operators with a show they trust.

Day One® exists to help founders and startup operators make better business decisions more often

Subscribe for helpful content from other successful founders, operators and investors

Join 755 other founders & investors receiving our emails. They're cool, are you? :)

* Regrettably, mel@canva.com is not on our list… yet.

Day One® is a registered trademark of W2D1 Media Pty Ltd. All rights reserved. © 2026 W2D1 Media Pty Ltd.

Day One® exists to help founders and startup operators make better business decisions more often

Subscribe for helpful content from other successful founders, operators and investors

Join 755 other founders & investors receiving our emails. They're cool, are you? :)

* Regrettably, mel@canva.com is not on our list… yet.

Day One® is a registered trademark of W2D1 Media Pty Ltd. All rights reserved. © 2026 W2D1 Media Pty Ltd.