fbpx

Elaine Stead discusses bravery, diversity, and changing the investing ecosystem

First Cheque

Elaine Stead_First Cheque_01

This show is part of the Day One Podcast Network dedicated to founders, operators and investors. Learn about new and upcoming shows by subscribing to the newsletter.

Do you want to learn from the best investors in the world or understand how they make their investment decisions? Sign up to our newsletter to get the next episode straight to your inbox.

Supported by:

SPONSOR_Turo_01
SPONSOR_Scendar_01

Powered by RedCircle

Summary

Elaine Stead joins the podcast to discuss bravery and courage in the investing world, particularly as a woman in the Australian ecosystem. She shares her journey as an investor and highlights the importance of investing in education and building networks.

Elaine also challenges the notion of being a contrarian investor and emphasizes the need for a high tolerance for risk. She discusses portfolio construction and the importance of managing risk and diversification.

The conversation also touches on the challenges faced by women in the industry and the need for change in the ecosystem.

About The Guest

Elaine Stead is a General Partner at M8 Ventures and an experienced investor in the Australian ecosystem. With nearly 100 investments under her belt, she is known for her bravery and courage in making investment decisions. She has a background in science and innovation and has built a strong network in the industry.

Key Takeaways

  • Investing in education is a crucial investment that can change the trajectory of one’s life.
  • Building networks is essential for success in the investing world, particularly for women.
  • Being a contrarian investor is about having a higher tolerance for risk and being able to see opportunities early.
  • The Australian ecosystem needs more diversity in capital allocation and investment decisions.
  • Wealth creation and equity allocation should be more inclusive to drive change in the industry.

Quotes

  • “Being brave is about being fearful of something, but doing it anyway.” – Elaine Stead
  • “Diversity in teams signals the ability to manage conflict and work with people who think differently.” – Elaine Stead
  • “Making room for others is a show of strength and confidence.” – Elaine Stead

Resources

  • M8 Ventures: Elaine Stead, the guest on the podcast, is the General Partner at M8 Ventures, a venture capital firm. (Timestamp: [00:00:49])
  • Day One Network: The podcast is part of the Day One network, dedicated to founders, operators, and investors. (Timestamp: [00:00:08])
  • Elaine Stead: A prominent figure in the Australian investing ecosystem, recognized for her experience and insights into investing. (Various Timestamps)
  • Alex Rampell: Mentioned by Maxine Minter in the context of investing perspectives. (Timestamp: [00:10:15])
  • South by Southwest Sydney: Elaine Stead mentions she will be on a panel at this event. (Timestamp: [00:25:20])
  • Aussie Angels: Discussed in the context of making investment accessible to a wider audience with lower thresholds. (Timestamp: [00:34:31])
  • Cindy Gallop: Moderator for a panel at South by Southwest Sydney, mentioned in the context of discussions around ecosystem changes. (Timestamp: [00:25:20])
  • Tribe Podcast: Previously discussed issues around diversity and returns in the investment ecosystem. (Timestamp: [00:26:20])
  • Shoes of Prey: A company that Elaine Stead invested in, which later failed. (Timestamp: [00:18:14])

Transcript

This transcript has been A.I. generated.

[00:00:00] Maxine Minter: Okay. Three, two, one. Hey, I’m Cheryl. I’m Maxine. This is First

[00:00:05] Cheryl Mack: Cheque, part of day one, the network dedicated to founders, operators,

[00:00:08] Maxine Minter: and investors. If you want to be a better early stage investor, this is the show for you.

[00:00:12] Elaine Stead: So TLDR, if you don’t

[00:00:13] Cheryl Mack: want to suck at investing, listen up.

[00:00:25] Maxine Minter: So I am super excited, super excited to have Elaine Stent on our podcast today on First Cheque. Elaine is the GP at M8 Ventures and an absolute OG of the Australian investing ecosystem. We were talking actually in the chat before this, she’s done almost a hundred investments. She’s like right up there alongside Rayn Ong as just, you know, investing in the Australian ecosystem.

More

[00:00:49] Maxine Minter: And has seen multiple cycles. So really excited to have her on to dive into how she thinks about bravery, how she thinks about courage in the investing world in Australia, especially as a woman. Uh, and especially over that period of time, you know, there’s been, uh, it’s been an incredible journey. And so excited to kind of chat through that.

[00:01:07] Maxine Minter: And also to talk about investing and portfolio construction. How do you think about that level of volume, pace, and all things investing? So I’m really excited to dive into today’s conversation.

[00:01:18] Elaine Stead: Yes. Thanks for having me, guys. It’s so nice to be here, and oh my goodness, rarefied air to be compared to rain, so,

[00:01:28] Maxine Minter: Oh,

[00:01:28] Cheryl Mack: no, absolutely.

[00:01:29] Cheryl Mack: It’s such a good comparison. I mean, like. One of the things I love about Elaine is that she’s just, like, not afraid to speak her mind, and every time I, I talk to her, she’s, I learn something, but I also get this, like, jolt of electricity that, like, I could do something cool, or, like, I could be brave like she is, and I just love that about you every time we spend time together.

[00:01:48] Cheryl Mack: So today I think I’m going to get a huge, uh, jolt of, uh, basically hit by lightning today.

[00:01:55] Elaine Stead: I’ve never been told that before, but that is such a lovely compliment, so thank you. I’m going to put that in my, can I put that in my LinkedIn profile? You

[00:02:04] Maxine Minter: sure can. Absolutely. Cheryl says you’re a lightning bolt.

[00:02:06] Elaine Stead: I just might say electrify as opposed to electrocute, I think that might be safer.

[00:02:11] Maxine Minter: Yeah. Electrified. Yes. Editorialized. Editorialized. Yeah. Absolutely. Yeah. And so we always open our conversations, this being a podcast about investing, to learn kind of how did you start? What was the first thing that you ever invested

[00:02:25] Elaine Stead: in? Yeah. Good, good question. So. The first kind of product that I invested in was my, the first house I bought, but I actually think you kind of alluded to it when you sent me over a couple of the questions you were going to ask today, which was education.

[00:02:40] Elaine Stead: So actually, like, if I think about what’s the asset that I invested in first, it was my education. I put myself through university, paid for all my textbooks, paid for my tuition, worked part time in two different jobs the entire time I was at university. So. It was one of those things that I kind of knew was just such an important thing for me to invest in to change the trajectory of my life.

[00:03:06] Elaine Stead: And it’s not because I had a bad life. I had really, you know, wonderful childhood and a mother who is a unconditional supporter and, you know, my sister is amazing. But like, you know, I was a child of migrants who didn’t have very much. We didn’t have very much growing up. So. I knew kind of if I was going to not just do the same thing all my family did, which are all very noble jobs and careers, I would have to invest in university.

[00:03:34] Elaine Stead: So that’s kind of my very first investment. But the first actual proper like financial investment I made where there was actually some return was my, was the first house I bought. Yeah, so

[00:03:44] Maxine Minter: cool. I actually think investment in education is one of the most consistent and best investments you see kind of across asset classes that the majority of the population makes.

[00:03:55] Maxine Minter: If you just think about it for a moment and think about the wage change, for example, as the return profile investing in education, but Um, not just wage change, but lifestyle change, community change, like all of the compounding benefits of university, it’s consistently shown to be one of the best investments you can

[00:04:13] Elaine Stead: make.

[00:04:14] Elaine Stead: Absolutely. And it wasn’t just that it gave me a really great educational foundation for my career because I, you know, did a science degree and then eventually did honors and then a PhD. And that sort of led to a career in innovation. And of course that led to a different financial outcome than had I stayed in retail, which is what I was doing when I was at university.

[00:04:37] Elaine Stead: Working at the local H& M. Yeah, exactly. I was the Christmas casual at Meyer for, I don’t know, seven years running or something and worked at Burnside Village as well as a, incredible, you know, a retail assistant, which, which I loved. And actually was a great foundation for a whole bunch of other reasons.

[00:04:54] Elaine Stead: Customer service. I think people who work in this industry. Who you can tell whether they’ve had some sort of background in hospitality or retail because of the way that they interact with people. It’s just different like that. That is an apprenticeship all in of itself, but I’m digressing. The other bit that was really important for my education investment was my networks.

[00:05:14] Elaine Stead: So, you know, I went to an. all girls school, all girls Catholic school. And if you think about who are the people you need to know to have a career in this particular industry, it was probably not a whole bunch of women at a Catholic school. The networks I needed to interact with were the ones that I was given the opportunity to build while I was at university.

[00:05:35] Elaine Stead: And so, and those, those networks have stood me in amazing stead over the rest of my career. So actually where I think the investment is is, yes, it was a learning exercise and a knowledge exercise, but the network side of it was equally important. Yeah. That social capital, I think is the bit that. is actually really hard for a lot of female founders and, sorry, women founders and women in the investment

[00:05:58] Maxine Minter: space.

[00:05:59] Maxine Minter: I think that’s a really interesting point, like the importance of

[00:06:01] Cheryl Mack: network. Yeah, when you go to university, like you build a network that you wouldn’t have built anywhere else and it’s people who are chasing their goals, people who are chasing careers, and you just tend to like grow up together and it kind of creates that like cohort feel where you’re like invest in everyone else’s success.

[00:06:19] Cheryl Mack: I would say like I didn’t I don’t remember much of what I learned at university, but the people and the networks and like, also the ability to work together in like, tough groups. Sure, I took that home with me. But yeah, then I think the networks, it’s very similar, like you see a lot of similarities between like, when you come and join a startup ecosystem in like, I, you know, I moved from Canada to Australia, like building your network within an ecosystem, I think has a lot of similarities to like joining a new university and growing your ecosystem and community there.

[00:06:47] Elaine Stead: Absolutely. Yeah. And, you know, you get to benefit from their networks and the people that I happen to, to have the privilege of falling into, you know, their circle were incredibly well connected. I would never have gotten access to those people or their networks had I not gone to university. So great investment.

[00:07:06] Elaine Stead: You know, there’s that old saying, like you’re the product of the five people you spend the most time with. And so that was a really important intervention at a really critical time in my life. That I’m really grateful for. That’s awesome. But you know,

[00:07:18] Cheryl Mack: Maxine, one of the things that you and I talk about is like, that to be a successful investor, like, the pinnacle of being successful is to be contrarian and also to be right.

[00:07:28] Cheryl Mack: And I think that that’s something that, you know, Elaine has made a lot of bets in her life. Like you said, she’s, she’s made a hundred investments. You know, and I’d be willing to bet a lot of those were contrarian and right. And I’d love to hear your perspective

[00:07:38] Elaine Stead: on that, Elaine. Yeah, it’s so funny. Like, I think, you know, that, that saying about being contrarian and right is temporal, right?

[00:07:45] Elaine Stead: Like, you can’t be contrarian forever. Because eventually, for that investment to be successful, everyone needs to eventually cotton on, right? So, um, that’s true. I think you just have to be, you want a big enough gap though, right? That’s it. Yeah. There needs to be a big enough gap. But, um, so I actually don’t think I’m a contrarian investor.

[00:08:05] Elaine Stead: Interesting. Believe it or not. I think I am. And, and I don’t actually think I’m particularly different as an investor to, to the kind of the rest of our cohort. I think if I, you know, I’ve invested with a lot of other investors along the way, and I actually think like practically and operationally we approach things relatively similarly.

[00:08:26] Elaine Stead: I think the reason I have been able to navigate a career in venture is because I think I’m able to see opportunities and not be. So scared by the risk because I can see a pathway to managing it, or if it’s risk that I think can’t be managed, then, then I won’t invest. So I think it’s, it’s more of a tolerance for risk than anything else.

[00:08:50] Elaine Stead: Not necessarily compared to my counterparts in the industry, but I think that’s how you become a good investor is you’re able to sort of see opportunities early. And Not be too freaked out by the risks so you are able to make a bet and so in that way Maybe you can say contrarian because I might have seen some opportunities a bit earlier And you know, I have invested being first cheque in on a bunch of unicorns in Australia And so by that metric, I guess you can say yes, I was able to spot some things early But I don’t actually think I’m that contrarian.

[00:09:23] Elaine Stead: I think particularly given the last 10 years has been focused on kind of later stage investments, like things that are, that have a bit more traction in the market. And you know, you’re, you’re definitely not contrarian once you’re sort of saying something that’s already got product market fit and a whole bunch of customers, they’ve done the work for you.

[00:09:41] Elaine Stead: Um, you know, it’s, it’s then about, well, how do you supercharge that company to help it grow? And that’s a different skillset to being contrarian, I think, but both can get great venture type returns, if you can manage the opportunity and the risk profile adequately, I think.

[00:09:56] Maxine Minter: That’s super interesting. It, uh, it makes me think, like, that adage, contrarian and right, I wonder if it was developed in a time of the venture ecosystem that we have now passed, in that it was developed in a time of the ecosystem when There were less participants and there was less risk appetite, right?

[00:10:15] Maxine Minter: Whereas now it feels like quite a mature ecosystem, at least in the US, and it’s increasingly mature in the Australian ecosystem. Now, I wonder, I mean, your comments there are reminiscent for me of Alex Rampell from A16. He has a very similar perspective, right? Like it’s not really about being contrarian anymore.

[00:10:33] Maxine Minter: It’s about seeing stuff super early and just earlier than everyone else. And so that then, you know, other people see it and they get really excited and then you see that kind of consensus around a business and then Yes. You’re kind of up and to the right as they grow that, that organization. And so I wonder in the Australian ecosystem, if you can still be contrarian by being comfortable with a high level of risk.

[00:10:59] Maxine Minter: I think

[00:10:59] Elaine Stead: it’s more that you can definitely be contrarian at any point, but I think it’s, it’s more important early to be contrarian because it’s, it’s hard to sort of say a company that’s It’s 10 years old and still struggling and say, but I’ve got a thesis that this is really going to pop at some point.

[00:11:17] Elaine Stead: But I think when, when companies are really early and are untested, if perhaps you can just see a little farther ahead and you can see where the market is moving, other people have sort of written it off as not being all that interesting yet, but you know, you can say. I can see an, an, a thesis and an opportunity here.

[00:11:35] Elaine Stead: I think you can be, definitely be contrarian. I think you almost by definition have to be at that really early stage because if you’re the first cheque in, you’re seeing something that other people are not seeing. And as a result of that, at that early stage, you have to have a higher tolerance for risk because You know, the majority of the attrition rate over a number of years is going to be really high for companies that you invest in when, you know, they’re pre product or pre product launch.

[00:12:02] Elaine Stead: And so I think the risk is a, is a function of it as opposed to needs to be associated with it. And so then, you know, you need a portfolio construction approach that enables you to manage that risk and, and build out some diversification so that you can tolerate that attrition. And have enough bets so that the numbers game makes sense in order to generate the venture type returns that you’ve, you know, hopefully promised your investors you’ll, you’ll target.

[00:12:27] Elaine Stead: And

[00:12:27] Cheryl Mack: that is something we’ll jump in a little bit around your portfolio strategy. Yeah. That’s what we, I think that was one of the topics we wanted to dive into.

[00:12:35] Elaine Stead: Yeah, for sure. I’m happy

[00:12:36] Maxine Minter: to touch on that. Right. I’m trying to work out which direction to go, like to which bag. Yeah, I think I, where I would really like to go first.

[00:12:43] Maxine Minter: Is that thing you mentioned just there kind of looking out into the future and being like, no, I think that this can get to a certain scale and it might not be abundantly clear today, or I’ve just done the work relative to other investors to kind of see where this can go and see the world through the founder’s eyes.

[00:13:01] Maxine Minter: What jumps out to me is the. Conviction in your abilities by doing that. And also the bravery, because a lot of it is, as I mentioned in the entry, you know, a lot of it is just saying like, I don’t know, but I’m willing to take that risk. I am going to step into that unknown and be brave as I hold that space.

[00:13:20] Maxine Minter: And in a whole bunch of different categories, my observation of you is just brave. Right. You are very excellent at stepping into a space and being like, I know this to be true, or I think this to be true. And I’m going to hold my ground on it because that is the right thing to do. And I would love to know just maybe from the ground up, like where did that come from?

[00:13:38] Maxine Minter: How did you develop that? Or is it innate? Is it just there for you naturally?

[00:13:42] Elaine Stead: Yeah, good, good question. So I think there’s different types of bravery, right? So I think from an investment standpoint, being brave enough to kind of take some risk and make certain investments that perhaps not everyone else is doing is a function of your confidence around.

[00:14:02] Elaine Stead: The investment thesis that you have, right? And I think you can bolster your confidence and build your conviction that allows you to be brave in that investment decision by doing analysis and, and doing the work as you just said, Maxine, I think that that has been my experience of how I’ve been able to make some investment decisions, which at the time seemed risky or challenging, but eventually paid off.

[00:14:28] Elaine Stead: I think being brave though in your kind of personal life or outside of just the investment decision paradigm, I think is a different thing that comes not necessarily from confidence that you’ve done the work. I think that’s a function of a whole bunch of other things and. A lot of people are brave, you know, I consider bravery being fearful of something, but doing it anyway.

[00:14:52] Elaine Stead: Yeah. It’s a good definition. It’s not about not being fearful. It’s about absolutely not being fearful about what the outcomes can be, but feeling like you have to do it anyway. I don’t have to do it or will do it anyway for whatever reason that is. And for me in my personal or professional life, so not just about investment decisions, the bravery comes from a principled place, I think.

[00:15:16] Elaine Stead: So, you know, when I’ve stood up to organizations or institutions or stood up for organizations and institutions, it’s been because I was. really certain about a principle or, or really valued a principle that I felt was being contravened and that principle was really important to me. It didn’t mean I wasn’t fearful or incredibly concerned about what the outcomes might be, but it was because I couldn’t, it wasn’t, I couldn’t live with myself if I didn’t do it, right?

[00:15:50] Elaine Stead: So it becomes like a, you can’t not do it. But rather than it’s, Oh, I’m going to choose to be brave today. It’s more like, I actually won’t be able to live with myself if I don’t do it. So I’ve got to kind of step in or step up.

[00:16:03] Maxine Minter: I think it makes it 10 times more impressive to me, that bravery, right? To look that fear straight in the eye or that risk straight in the eye and be like, I am consciously and thoughtfully going to do this thing that makes me quake in my boots because there is a change in the world.

[00:16:21] Maxine Minter: that I want to see. Yeah. And I am taking that risk. And I think, I think it is so important because, especially in the Australian ecosystem, my observation is that there are, there is behavior by media, also by industry participants, especially in venture, but also across the investing ecosystem that for women, when things don’t go as planned or risk materializes, which we are all taking, There is a personal assassination that occurs, not a professional assessment of their skill or talent.

[00:16:56] Maxine Minter: And actually in the prep for this conversation, Cheryl and I were trying to work out, could we think of a man who’d been professionally assassinated? As a result of an investment decision, I asked Maxine, she’s like both here and in the us she’s

[00:17:11] Cheryl Mack: like, I, I can think of lots of men who have been, you know, canceled because of the Me Too movement.

[00:17:15] Cheryl Mack: And I was like, but can you think of a single man who’s been singled out because of an investment that they’ve made? And the answer was no. And I was like, but think of how many women we know who have been singled out because of investment that they, investments that they’ve made. Like that is. For lack of a better word, totally

[00:17:31] Maxine Minter: fucked up.

[00:17:33] Maxine Minter: I think the way you phrased it was, yeah, they got singled out for being a scumbag. Not for a decision. I was like, yeah, they scumbag, not investment decisions.

[00:17:43] Elaine Stead: Like, yeah. Yeah. And to be fair, like I was to maybe put a bit of context around that to be fair to the media. So I, I got singled out for two reasons.

[00:17:53] Elaine Stead: One because. A company that I was a director of was the target of a activist short attack. And that caused lots of kind of negative allegations to be bandied about, um, about the company and about us as, as executives in that. And that’s a bit different to being singled out for an investment that you made, but I also was singled out for that.

[00:18:14] Elaine Stead: So in the context of all of that. At the time, a company that I’d invested in, Shoes Of Prey, eventually had failed and we put it into voluntary administration. And yeah, like my involvement in leading that investment was definitely, um, I was targeted for that in the same way it’s Jax was targeted for the investment in Milk Run and, you know, we could name a whole bunch of others, but I won’t to save there.

[00:18:40] Elaine Stead: Mental health, but and you’re right that that same thing doesn’t happen to men and even in the case of of blue sky where I was targeted a lot, you know, most of the directors on the board were not. So it was really kind of me and the CEO, even though I had spent the least amount of time on that board and managed one of the smallest, in fact, immaterial parts of the business from a public company perspective.

[00:19:07] Elaine Stead: So I think the point you’re trying to make is right though. So I, but I just wanted to be clear, like, you know, there were a couple of reasons they were targeting. And I do think it is absolutely something that women entrepreneurs and women investors do bring into the decision making process of whether they make an investment and also whether they get into this industry.

[00:19:28] Elaine Stead: Because to be honest, I think where it. Um, where the rubber hits the road on this is it’s not something the men in our industry ever have to worry about. They absolutely do not have to worry about being professionally canceled if they may, if they have an investment that fails. And that gives them an advantage because it’s just like the mental energy of having to worry about that or deal with it if it does happen is just doesn’t exist for them in the same way as the worry of being assaulted at an event like I was a few weeks ago.

[00:20:02] Elaine Stead: It’s not a worry for the men in our industry because they do not have to worry about being sexually harassed and the impact that that will have on their ability to do their job. And so I think there’s just this mental energy that goes into. Kind of how we operate in this industry, that the men that we work with just do not need to even bother themselves with.

[00:20:24] Elaine Stead: And I think that gives them an advantage or it puts us at a disadvantage and it does come into this concept of how we consider risk because am I going to invest in this company. That has a high profile and therefore will be covered by media. And therefore if it fails, we’ll be uber covered by media where my reputation could be on the chopping block when others will have a very different.

[00:20:55] Elaine Stead: And I think it takes a lot of mental energy as well for us to look at those things and not make them part of the decision making process. Right? So I honestly don’t think I do make, consider that now, even after, you Uh, being kind of the target of a whole bunch of media bullying as a result of investments that I’ve made.

[00:21:15] Elaine Stead: But I’m, I’m sure that it’s part of my decision making process and I have to be conscious of that as a bias and not let that integrate into my decision making process and just be really true to the investment thesis. Wow, I

[00:21:28] Maxine Minter: think that’s the yeah. Wow.

[00:21:30] Cheryl Mack: Like yeah, just wow. No, but I think when when I’m

[00:21:34] Maxine Minter: Just wow, no, but when

[00:21:36] Cheryl Mack: Maxine and I were talking about this I was kind of like well How does this factor in like the investment thesis when women are thinking about well if I make this investment and it’s inherently risky because in Early stage investing is like, what if I get professionally cancelled?

[00:21:49] Cheryl Mack: And, and how does that factor into your investment decision? So I think the way that you frame that is like, look, there’s inherent bias there, but at the same time, I’m conscious of that. And I work really hard to not let that factor into my investment decision, I think is inspiring.

[00:22:04] Elaine Stead: That’s what I try to do.

[00:22:06] Elaine Stead: I think of it like the women in this industry. Or underrepresented minorities will stop, right? So this isn’t just a gender thing. Yeah. I like the Ginger Rogers to the Fred Astaire’s in our industry and that they have to. Do all the things that they do, but they have to do it backwards and in heels. And by that I mean, you know, we have to deal with all these other things that they just do not.

[00:22:28] Elaine Stead: And try and cut out that noise as a result. The challenge with that, I think, is that people say a lot. But the only thing you’re measured on as a, as a, an investor or a venture capitalist is your returns. And that is only partially true because absolutely we’re measured on our returns. Certainly you will never get a second fund if your first fund is not successful.

[00:22:53] Elaine Stead: So in that way, yes. But the LPs who are allocating capital, when we’re talking about financial services and financial products and people who are managing other people’s money, people are looking for confidence. They want to be confident in the people that they’re allocating capital to. And if you’re someone who has had to hustle and fight and kind of, you know, deal with all of these other bits of noise in the background.

[00:23:19] Elaine Stead: As an entrepreneur, you get credit for that. As an investor, you absolutely do not get credit for that. You need to make it look easy. And it’s really hard to make it look easy when you’re dealing with all this other bullshit in the background as well. And I think that is part of why there is this disconnect between how much women get funded, whether they’re founders or whether they’re fund managers and, and men, because it’s really hard to show that you’ve got your shit together and you’re super confident when you’re dealing with all this other bullshit.

[00:23:51] Cheryl Mack: That men simply don’t have to deal with. That’s

[00:23:53] Elaine Stead: right. You need to make it look easy and it’s not.

[00:23:56] Maxine Minter: Right. I think this is why bravery for you is just so amazing because you, you know, make it look easy no matter how bumpy, how bumpy the road is. I do wonder, I mean, I think this is a moment in time. And looking backwards, and I’m a big believer that the world, like, nothing changes if nothing changes.

[00:24:14] Maxine Minter: So our generation of folks are the transition team to change the way that our ecosystem is working. And so what do you think the path out of that is? What are the things that we do, we can do as an ecosystem, this week, this month, this year, that changes this? Especially because

[00:24:34] Cheryl Mack: Maxine and I, prior to this, were, were concerned that if we were to bring up this topic of conversation on this podcast with you, that like, we might alienate the next generation of female investors wanting to come in or underrepresented investors who wanted to come in because we might tell them how hard it is and they simply might just say, well, screw it.

[00:24:55] Cheryl Mack: I’m out. Like, that’s too hard. So

[00:24:58] Elaine Stead: we don’t want to do that. Right? Yeah. I definitely don’t want to put people off because I think it is such a brilliant. industry and such a brilliant calling to be able to play this role. So yeah, I certainly don’t want to put people off, but I also don’t want to, I’m a big believer and not rah rah ing when it doesn’t like, I want to be realistic about what the challenges are.

[00:25:20] Elaine Stead: So I’m actually going to be on a panel at South by Southwest Sydney about talking about exactly what can we do as an ecosystem. To, to fix some of these things. And the very great Cindy Gallop is moderating that panel. Um, so it should be awesome and entertaining. So we will talk about that. But I think there’s a couple of things.

[00:25:44] Elaine Stead: One, everyone knows the data is there that diverse teams, diverse investors, diverse ecosystem generates better returns. Better outcomes on the, in the companies, we talked about this on the tribe podcast a few weeks ago about the data that shows SAS companies outperform by like three times, 300 percent when there are at least a third of the management or leadership team, female, for example, like there is so much data that reinforces this concept and yet nothing changes because we are not making these decisions based on data or what’s actually happening.

[00:26:20] Elaine Stead: Going to generate the best outcome Decisions are being made based on self-interest, , just to be really blunt about it. So we need to change the narrative about why focusing on that will actually be in everyone’s self-interest. And so it’s that emotional narrative that we have yet to tap into because the data is there.

[00:26:41] Elaine Stead: It’s not a data driven issue at all. I think the way it changes is the capital allocators and then it trickles down from there. So I think. The LPs who are allocating capital should be allocating capital to fund managers who are investing in diverse teams or have a diversity quota of some description in their investment thesis.

[00:27:04] Elaine Stead: Because if they put pressure on, in the same way as there was pressure on ESG and meeting certain, you know, net zero initiatives, if it is not imposed by the capital allocators, it will never be imposed by the fund managers or it will be, but it will happen really slowly over time and it’s going to take a generation.

[00:27:23] Elaine Stead: So I think that needs to happen first and foremost, and there’s no reason it shouldn’t because the data. Supports it . So I just don’t understand why this is, uh, it shouldn’t really be a controversial comment. And then I think it flows down from there. So if the capital allocators, the LPs, the superannuation funds change their allocation requirements, then the fund managers will.

[00:27:47] Elaine Stead: If the fund managers do, then the startups will, and all of a sudden we’ll get like a supercharge for change and. And that’s what I think is, is needed to kind of move the dial in this ecosystem because it absolutely does not represent the community it serves.

[00:28:02] Maxine Minter: I love that. I wonder for any Superfund manager that is listening or anyone who can influence those Superfund managers, please start thinking about how they, how we do this because in a lot of other verticals, you’re right, like if you, the kind of change maker is the top of the incentive tree and in our industry, the top of the incentive tree.

[00:28:23] Maxine Minter: is LPs. I’ve actually seen in the U. S. it come the other way as well. I’ve started to see founders start asking fund The, uh, investors that they’re working with, who are the LPs of your fund? And essentially, who will I be creating wealth for when I’m successful? And even just that question requires that as a fund manager, you front up and be like, well, this is the demographics of my LP base.

[00:28:50] Maxine Minter: This is who, uh, you know, this is my partnership and this is. Uh, the demographics of our LP base, and I think just that question can drive, um, transparency and behavior change in that group as well. I also know that, um, Preethi and, uh, a kind of wider community of folks are starting to ask fund managers to report on the demographics of their LPs and their, uh, the portfolio that we work for, and I think that’s really powerful as well.

[00:29:14] Maxine Minter: I just, I think that I think that helps. Transparency is really wonderful

[00:29:18] Elaine Stead: here. Yeah. Transparency helps. That’s really cool. But we need more than transparency. 100%. Because I think a lot of funds think that they’re doing enough by simply reporting their numbers. Oh, look how many female founded companies we saw.

[00:29:31] Elaine Stead: Oh, great. But how is just reporting those numbers changing who gets access to capital? Yeah. You know, I, I do think there needs to be expectations around diversity. Thresholds, quotas for the companies that are investing. You don’t have to have X amount of female led companies, but if the companies you’re investing in don’t have diversity at the leadership level, then I think you have a problem.

[00:29:56] Elaine Stead: I think a lot of companies and fund managers, I think the reason they don’t have diversity. And I think I’m going to write a blog post about this now that, now that we’re having this conversation. Yay. You heard it here first. Diversity is not, it doesn’t make you immune to failure and it certainly won’t.

[00:30:11] Elaine Stead: Ensure that you get good outcomes and good returns, but it will expose your weaknesses. Yeah, and by that what I mean is if you have a diverse team, what you are actually signaling to the world is that you can work functionally and well with a bunch of people who are not like you, who think differently, who see the world differently and.

[00:30:34] Elaine Stead: What happens in those teams, those diverse teams, where there’s people who have different perspectives, and this is all sorts of diversity, people from different backgrounds, different experience bases, gender, cultural, whatever. If you have a bunch of people who think differently, firstly, I think that’s necessary in order to solve problems that haven’t been solved before.

[00:30:53] Elaine Stead: I think that’s what’s needed for innovation and creativity. If you have those people and they’re working functionally, then what you’ve actually done is you’ve signaled to the world that you can manage conflict, the conflict that’s associated with building and nurturing teams who think differently. And if you can, if you can navigate that conflict, you’re actually showing that you’re more sophisticated than Joey bagger donuts down the road, who was not working with a diverse team, right?

[00:31:18] Elaine Stead: Just a bunch of beige donuts. And so what you’re actually, what you’re signaling is a confidence. That, like when I look at teams that are not diverse, I see people who are not confident to do their job without people who make them feel comfortable. And that’s a bad, that is a risk issue that I think is a massive red flag.

[00:31:41] Elaine Stead: So I think if you’ve got diversity in your team, what you’re actually showing is that we don’t have any weaknesses here on how we manage people, how we build teams, how we nurture people who think differently. And we’re prepared to be challenged about what we do and what we say. So that’s why I think diversity is actually a really positive signal and a lack of diversity is a really bad red flag.

[00:32:05] Maxine Minter: 100%. I couldn’t agree more.

[00:32:07] Elaine Stead: 100%. Sorry, I’ll get off my high horse

[00:32:09] Maxine Minter: now. No, I love it. I love, I actually, um, there was a thread there I love to pull, which is about like. wealth creation and who has the power to make these kinds of decisions. And maybe to join you on a soapbox of my very own, I’ve recently become aware of the difference in equity allocation in Australia versus the U.

[00:32:32] Maxine Minter: S. Actually in Australia, Australian startups do not share the pie as heavily with employees as we do in the U. S. And I think this is a real problem because we might start to solve the participation challenge, which then leads to, in the U. S., has led to wealth creation for a very large number of diverse fund managers.

[00:32:58] Maxine Minter: And those diverse fund managers are then deploying capital into communities that they identify with. because they are more capable of identifying opportunity in those groups and generating significant alpha in these funds, like delivering really starting to deliver really wonderful returns. And we don’t have that flywheel that’s working in Australia yet.

[00:33:17] Maxine Minter: And so I think something to think about is also. creation as angel investors, as operator angels in Australia and also as employees in Australia. And that being available to a wider group of people, I obviously just think Aussie Angels is the best thing since sliced bread coming into this eco system for that, because it means that you can.

[00:33:42] Maxine Minter: Access is at a much lower place. Absolutely right. Like syndicates are being run a thousand to kind of 2501st investment, and that is affordable for most people operating in professional jobs. Assuming we don’t have caring responsibilities in those kind of things that, you know, can disadvantage here. But I do think that there’s a, I’m really excited to see that flywheel start working and I would love to see more.

[00:34:05] Maxine Minter: Founders consider more substantial equity grants for their employees so that that flywheel continues to move. Like, I think that this is a multifactorial solution to an incredibly complex problem. I don’t think any single one of these levers is going to move the dial in our lifetime, but I do think if all of us play our part and think about like, what is the systemic compounding impact of the decisions we’re making today, we will move it.

[00:34:31] Maxine Minter: I think we will be able to see it in our lifetime, or at least I really hope we will.

[00:34:35] Elaine Stead: I agree.

[00:34:35] Cheryl Mack: Yeah, absolutely. I think it’s, it’s this thing that I’ve talked about a little bit, which is like the cycle of funding, right? It’s not like the, the men have set out to like exclude us. It’s just that when you have a typically male founder base, they go out to their friends and family for their first raise.

[00:34:52] Cheryl Mack: And who are their friends and family? They tend to be male because You know, I tend to have more female friends, males tend to have to have more male friends. And so, when they make it big, and they make a return, who gets rich? Their friends and family who happen to be male, and then that cycle of funding continues because those people either start a company or invest in the next generation, and when they look at the pattern of, well, who just made me rich?

[00:35:16] Cheryl Mack: Then they reinvest in that, and I think breaking that cycle in many ways, some of which is the employee allocation, other, I think, like, Founders asking, like, who, who am I going to make rich when I make it big is really important, and so I love that you say that, like, um, you know, you’re seeing funds in the U.

[00:35:34] Cheryl Mack: S. being asked that question, and founders having the bravery to ask that question of the funds that are taking that money, um, on the flip side, like, I think we’re just starting to see some Uh, founders here asking that, like making room, um, not asking the question of funds. I’d love to see more of that if anyone, if there are founders listening in, you should start asking that question.

[00:35:55] Cheryl Mack: Otherwise, I think as an investor, like when I talk to founders, um, I like to highlight that it’s important to make room for diverse. Investors on your cap table and I’ve been fortunate enough to be able to get in, um, to some great rounds because of other investors who have said, Hey, have you thought of including females on your, on your cap table?

[00:36:14] Cheryl Mack: Like, I don’t see any females here. Would you like to? You know, would you like to be introduced?

[00:36:18] Elaine Stead: Yeah. And I think your platform, Cheryl, has been really instrumental to activating a lot of women investors who otherwise couldn’t access the asset class because, you know, thresholds for investment just didn’t make it possible.

[00:36:31] Elaine Stead: So kind of your ability to fractionalize it for investors is really, is a game changer.

[00:36:38] Maxine Minter: And I think something that we’ve kind of alluded to here, but something to call out is that gender is not the only element of diversity as well. There are so many different ways that we are different, so many ways that the different perspectives we can bring can be helpful to each other.

[00:36:53] Maxine Minter: And so, wonderful, you know, it’s a very visible difference that we have, but it is You know, not the only one. So also thinking about as we’re thinking about what change we’re trying to make in the world and push forward, you know, thinking about who are those people that you want to tag into deals? Who do you want to kind of bring around the table?

[00:37:09] Maxine Minter: How might you be able to share your opportunity around so that more people can access it? I think is a really win win win. It’s a worthwhile question to ask yourself every single time you’re in that, you’re in that moment.

[00:37:21] Elaine Stead: Absolutely. And it’s such a, it’s such a show of strength too. Like if, if you can make room for others, it just shows that you’re not being, you know, elbowing people out and being defensive.

[00:37:30] Elaine Stead: I think it’s, it’s such a show of confidence and strength. 100%. And I

[00:37:34] Cheryl Mack: guess on that note, as, uh, one of our final questions speaking about uh, show of strength. Our final question we like to ask all guests is, what is your biggest Big Gahona’s moment? So a time that you were really brave and I know you’ve got lots of brave moments Elaine, but maybe your biggest one.

[00:37:50] Cheryl Mack: Yeah,

[00:37:51] Elaine Stead: so I think, I think that there were kind of two. So I imagine most people expect me to say taking the financial review to court. I didn’t actually think that was particularly brave. I felt like I had no other choice, so I didn’t think that was particularly brave. I think where I was maybe a bit brave was Writing and being very public about my mental health struggles over that period of time and, and having to be quite open about being quite suicidal because I thought that would probably tarnish me forever as, uh, someone who wasn’t able to manage the stress or cope with the industry.

[00:38:39] Elaine Stead: But I sort of thought that the benefit of sharing that with people would outweigh the potential downside. I’m sure people still think I’m a slightly crazy person and I’m never going to change those people’s minds, but only

[00:38:54] Maxine Minter: in the best way,

[00:38:55] Elaine Stead: but hopefully, hopefully what it, what it does do is it’s allowed me to be, it’s allowed a lot of founders in the.

[00:39:04] Elaine Stead: In the sector to be more open with me about the challenges from a mental health perspective. And so I think that was probably a bit of bravery for me personally, more so than, than the other stuff, which was a bit more public, I think. Wow. Yeah,

[00:39:20] Maxine Minter: 100%. That’s very brave. That is very brave. I also. To echo your point, being brave to show that vulnerability, especially in that moment, I think just speaks to the strength and the confidence, you know, even in that very scary moment to share that, to give permission for other people to be able to share that with you in the future.

[00:39:44] Maxine Minter: It’s pretty amazing. Yeah. A hundred percent.

[00:39:46] Elaine Stead: Thanks. Yeah. Um, it’s better out than in, I think, you know, like, uh, I know a lot of people don’t want to look weak in this industry for all the reasons we talked about, about how people want to be confident to give you their money and, and for you to manage it.

[00:40:02] Elaine Stead: And there is this temptation to make it look easy. But I think you’re doing the industry a disservice if you kind of wear that mask all the time. Like you’ve got to, you’ve got to be good at what you do. I think you’ve also got to be human or else like it’ll come out eventually in some unhealthy way. So you might as well be transparent about it.

[00:40:23] Elaine Stead: And I think this industry is. It, the whole job that we do, the three of us, is about people. And so being able to share where you’ve struggled or things that you’ve done that you’ve made errors on or things that you’ve done that you’ve gotten right, that’s the value that we bring to the group. People that we work with, so you kind of have to be open about that stuff.

[00:40:45] Elaine Stead: I think it makes it a bit hard to help people navigate this entrepreneurial path. If you’re constantly telling them how great you are and all the wonderful things that you know, I think you got to share the shit stuff too, or else it’s a bit kind of hollow. Yeah.

[00:41:02] Maxine Minter: 100%.

[00:41:03] Cheryl Mack: Yeah. I think it’s important for the next generation of who we expect to follow in our footsteps, the next generation of diverse investors who will be deploying capital, that they need to know that it’s, it’s not easy, but it’s doable.

[00:41:17] Cheryl Mack: And it’s not too hard either. We don’t want to go the other way. But I think you being brave and sharing that type of stuff does help. The next generation know that like, this is part of taking that next step and having and showing that strength around being an investor, but also being vulnerable.

[00:41:34] Elaine Stead: Yeah.

[00:41:35] Elaine Stead: Well said.

[00:41:36] Maxine Minter: I also think it just makes you a better investor. It definitely does.

[00:41:40] Elaine Stead: I do too. I mean, the more times that you’ve dealt with a crisis or some sort of failure or a bad decision or not a bad decision, but just the outcome was bad, the more you can be, you can draw on that experience to help the companies that you’re working with.

[00:41:58] Elaine Stead: So I do think it makes you a better investor provided that you, you know, channel it. constructively. You use all of

[00:42:09] Cheryl Mack: that experience for the next investment.

[00:42:11] Maxine Minter: Yes. With investing, I actually think it might be one of the only industries where we get better with age. And I think that is material for Women, right?

[00:42:23] Maxine Minter: The like social norm of like, you get worse with age. Yeah. Is prevalent for us in so many different verticals. Yeah. But investing

[00:42:30] Elaine Stead: Yeah, you don’t age out of it. You get better because your experience base should make you a better investor over time. It’s not like we’re professional athletes where everything starts to you know, fall over at 30.

[00:42:42] Elaine Stead: Dwindle after 30. So you should get better. The challenge is to um To stay in the game, right? Because you can only stay in the game if you’re continuing to deliver returns for your investors. And so. And deploy. It should be actually a bit of a self sourcing pudding or self selecting because you won’t get to have that experience if you’re not good at what you do.

[00:43:05] Elaine Stead: And it’s self sourcing pudding. But you’re, you’re right, Maxine, you should get better as, as you get older.

[00:43:11] Maxine Minter: Yeah. Or edit yourself out of the game if you’re like, yeah, this is a very expensive thing to be bad at. Yeah.

[00:43:18] Elaine Stead: Yeah. And it is, right? It is very expensive to be bad at for you and for your investors.

[00:43:23] Elaine Stead: Right. And not just expensive from a cost perspective to be bad at it, right? Because as you guys know, it costs so much to set up a fund and a fund manager and, um, it’s expensive with time. Yeah. Because, you know, it’s a 10 year journey, even if you’re bad at it. Because you kind of have to manage the funds through to the end and so yeah, it’s, it’s not for the faint hearted kind of thing.

[00:43:46] Elaine Stead: Well,

[00:43:46] Cheryl Mack: I hope that one day I can be in your position to say I’ve got 100 investments that I’ve been a part of and I’ve been able to overcome a lot of challenges like you. So thank you so much for your time today. My pleasure. I’ve, true to

[00:44:01] Maxine Minter: form, learned

[00:44:01] Elaine Stead: so much. Thank you so much. Thanks for having me, guys.

[00:44:04] Elaine Stead: I really appreciate it. This was wonderful.

[00:44:07] Maxine Minter: And got my lightning bolt shot.

[00:44:10] Elaine Stead: And he’s still alive. That’s great. so much.

Less

This episode is supported by

Turo – The world’s largest car-sharing marketplace, and it’s the perfect app for travel.

The booking process is so convenient, you can get the car delivered and the hosts are super friendly.

Download the app today!

Scendar – Australia’s OG startup accounting firm catering to all stages of your business’ life.

Free 1 hour consultation about your Business’ growth plans and finance needs.

Contact Scendar today

The Day One Network

First Cheque is part of Day One, the podcast network dedicated to founders, operators & investors.

To learn more, join our newsletter to be notified of new and upcoming shows. The only content we create is content that will help Australian founders.

If you want to learn about upcoming guests and when a new First Cheque episode is available, join the First Cheque newsletter.

Sponsor the show

Want to become a sponsor? Send us an email.

Become a supporter, make more of these stories possible.

Follow on social